Euthanasia
Some prior reading is required for this lesson.
Esther's Guarded Condition
originally appeared in the July/August 2007 issue of Touchstone:
A Journal of Mere Christianity and is reprinted with permission.
www.touchstonemag.com
As the World Sees It
The questions of euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide are still
debated by those whose calling is Christian Ethics – but the world
by and large has accepted both as being ethical. We examine
the world’s view first.
The nature of man
Much of the debate is rooted in stating the nature of man.
The Christian view is very different from the view of the medical
community, as can be seen in the reading. It is useful to
see the world’s view:
-
Man is simply the cleverest of the primates. There is
nothing intrinsically different between man and chimpanzee;
we’re just higher up on the evolutionary scale. This might
not seem important until you remember that we regularly shoot
horses – euthanasia for animals has been accepted for generations.
It is considered a mercy to dumb animals. So why would
we not do so for the cleverest of the apes?
-
For those more forward, consider “bio-ethics.” The premise
of same is that anything which gets my genetic material into
the gene pool is intrinsically good. (So, for example,
I would help my kid brother because his genetic material is
so similar). This method often has a problem with knowing
why something is good or not – but it’s clear that the dying
are not going to contribute to the gene pool anymore – so why
continue to keep them alive?
-
For the medical professional, once it’s determined that someone
is terminal, the attitude changes from “save” to “dispose.”
In the coldest of ways, the terminally ill should be in hospice
– thus eliminating the perceived problems of hospital space
and medical victory.
How are ethics formed?
Some of the decisions outlined in the pre-reading might seem odd
at first. We need to consider how ethical decisions get made
in this environment:
-
First, there are what we may call “professional ethics” – the
written and unwritten codes of conduct which surround the culture
we call medicine. Most doctors don’t make ethical decisions;
they repeat them.
-
For many, “if it’s legal, it’s moral.” Ethical decisions
boil down to whatever the law will allow. If my emotions
tell me that euthanasia is a good thing, then we need only look
to the law to see if it’s OK. And sometimes, we don’t
even do that. Physician assisted suicide is legal in Oregon;
thirty-eight other states prohibit it.
-
On some matters, the medical profession is influenced by public
opinion. This has been a powerful factor in making abortion
acceptable. I can recall being told of a doctor who was
denied membership in the local AMA chapter because everyone
knew he did abortions. (This was before Roe v. Wade).
Today, such a doctor is perfectly acceptable – even lauded for
his “courage.”
Justification
But, we may ask, is there any possible justification for euthanasia
and physician assisted suicide? Here are three such arguments:
-
With regard to physician-assisted suicide, we may argue that
the patient – a free moral agent – makes the decision.
The doctor only gives the patient the means. It’s freedom
of choice.
-
Times have changed. When the Bible was written, anesthetics
were unknown. The first surgery using ether as an anesthetic
was performed in the 19th century. We no longer
can rely solely on the Bible (nor need we) to make ethical decisions
today. Indeed, it may be argued that God intended dental
work to be painful; why are you opposing God’s will by going
to a dentist who uses Novocain?
-
Finally, what if the patient wants to die? I know
of at least one woman who committed suicide because the pain
from the cancer became too much for her to bear. (This
was some years ago, when the use of morphine for cancer patients
was considered excessive). Should we oblige her to live
on in agony?
As the Scripture has it
If you ask the typical conservative Christian, “How do you make
ethical decisions?”, you will get an answer like, “From the Bible.”
But try as you might, euthanasia is mentioned nowhere in the Bible.
There are six suicides in the Scripture (Samson, Saul and his armor
bearer, Ahithophel, Zimri and Judas Iscariot) – and none of them
are condemned. So making ethical decisions about euthanasia
and assisted suicide will require a little more thought.
The nature of man
Your view of man very much determines your willingness to permit
euthanasia. Briefly, here’s man as presented in the Bible:
-
Man is created in the image of God – and therefore is qualitatively
different from animals. They shoot horses; they don’t
shoot people. And that’s how it should be.
-
That qualitative difference is the spirit of man – a gift from
God which returns to Him at death.
Therefore euthanasia and suicide both involve the rejection
of God’s gift.
-
Particularly for Christians, we are bought with a price.
We are therefore to honor God with our bodies, for we are not
our own. It’s not my existence; it’s the existence I borrow
from the I AM, redeemed at the Cross. I am not privileged,
therefore, to determine the hour of my death.
Two questions for Christians
We need to put a little organization in our thoughts. There
are really two separate questions involved in euthanasia:
-
Just how do Christians make ethical decisions, especially in
an area where there is no explicit scripture?
-
Should those ethical decisions have the force of law, or should
they apply to Christians only?
Christian ethical decisions
So just how do Christians make ethical decisions?
-
Where possible, we are to take the guidance given in the Scriptures.
The “gray areas” are usually found where there is no explicit
guidance.
-
In certain circumstances, these ethics are determined by the
professionals in the profession. Christian doctors should
be the primary source of medical ethics for doctors.
-
Sometimes, ethics for Christians are determined by opinion poll.
By this I mean that Christian leaders develop a consensus position
which is supported by the ordinary Christian. There is
no stricture in the Scriptures concerning drunk driving – but
the average Christian has a good idea of what the answer should
be.
-
Finally – and perhaps most important – there is the matter of
tradition. Tradition is simply the vote of those no longer
walking on top of the grass. Often enough we can trace
a moral position back in time to show that this is the consensus
of the church not only today – but back through time as well.
Christian Ethics and Public Life
So then, having made our ethical decision, should we campaign to
give it the force of law?
Can we “legislate morality?”
Sure we can. Bank robbery is clearly immoral, but not specifically
condemned in the Scripture (no banks, only moneylenders).
We legislate that kind of morality on a regular basis. But
there is a decision to make in so doing:
-
Should this moral decision be cast in law, so that the power
of the state will help eliminate the unethical behavior?
-
Or, should this decision be one that distinguishes the Christian
from the rest of the world?
An example might help: in the 19th century it was
common to find laws prohibiting adultery. A man could be jailed
for seducing another man’s wife. Today, marital faithfulness
is a sign of a Christian marriage – or at least should be.
We need to be aware of the enemy’s methods in this: In the
name of your principles, I demand the right to speak. In the
name of mine, I demand that you be silent. Those who want
to promote (e.g.) abortion are very strident in being heard – and
very strict about you being silent.
One principle which might help us is this: there exists what
is called “natural law.” For hundreds of years the English
law books did not contain a definition of murder – it was part of
the Common Law, unwritten but binding. It was “common” in
the sense that it bound all citizens – even non-Christians.
Bank robbery is wrong because robbery is wrong, and the Scripture
only adds to the voices proclaiming natural law.
Dealing with the other view
Esther’s condition (see reading) may teach us a few things which
will be pragmatic for us:
-
Get your legal documents in order – the living will and medical
power of attorney. Don’t leave such judgments to the doctor.
-
Prepare for the problem. If the environment is hostile,
be prepared to have someone with the dying person around the
clock. Know what his or her wishes are, and don’t hesitate
to speak up.
-
Be vigilant. Assume that the problem will arise, watch
for it, and consistently deal with it as you have planned.
Another point of view
If you detect that the author has been through this mill as well,
you are correct. I’ve had to deal with the doctor who was
perfectly willing to give someone more morphine even if the patient’s
blood pressure was 60/0. That’s an offer to “take care of
the problem for you.” At the time I faced the decision as
to whether or not to put a direct feeding tube into Mom’s stomach.
The doctors represented this as an “extraordinary measure.”
I asked the family if anyone had any thoughts on the subject.
Here’s what I got from one of my sons:
Dad,
This is my response to your call this evening. Let me say
first of all that I recognize that it's your decision and I will
honor whatever choice you make. I'm writing this more because
you asked for my opinion than because I have a great deal of certainty
about it. It seemed like you were leaning toward withdrawing
the feeding tube and, as you put it, "allowing nature to take its
course." That particular way of framing the issue sets off
alarm bells in my head, and I apologize if this sounds like I'm
back in my (thoroughly awful) criminal law class in school.
I am uncomfortable with the idea of withholding nutrition, even
though providing nutrition at this stage would in the doctors' opinions
require removal of the current feeding tube and insertion of a new
and more permanent one through more invasive means. As it's
been described to me, the permanent feeding tube doesn't seem an
extraordinary or disproportionate measure. Feeding a patient
seems more like part of ordinary care, not heroic measures.
It doesn't seem like the permanent feeding tube would materially
increase her suffering, and it also doesn't seem like it would interfere
with the palliative care the doctors are thinking of, even if it
would likely preclude improvement.
You mentioned that withdrawal of the feeding tube would likely result
in death within two weeks or so. I know that younger and healthier
people can survive somewhat longer without food, but if the period
is likely to be that long, then it looks uncomfortably like deliberate
starvation. I don't desire to prolong Grandma's suffering,
of course, but withholding nutrition seems like a step on to the
wrong side of the line.
To put the case strongly, she is still alive and it is possible
to keep her alive through means that don't strike me as excessive,
although they are clearly somewhat undignified (although I don't
see that having a nurse change the bedpan, for example, is particularly
more or less dignified under the circumstances). Nature and
Providence may take their courses as well with the feeding tube
as without it.
Obviously, I wasn't there to talk to the doctor, but it sounds like
something of a false dilemma problem: The doctors sound like
they're saying that the choices are (a) a feeding tube, which will
prolong suffering in a semi-comatose (translation: life not worth
living, in the doctors' view) state indefinitely, or (b) slow death
by malnutrition, but elimination of suffering. Put that way,
I have to fight the hypothetical (why will the feeding tube interfere
with elimination of suffering? why do we humans get to decide
whether life is or isn't worth living?). I don't mean to make
it sound like a law-school class discussion, and I'm sure the doctors
have the best of intentions, but in a profession dominated by amoral
narcissists, one learns to be suspicious of this sort of argument.
Those are my (unfortunately rather disjointed) thoughts. I
think I'd opt for the permanent feeding tube based on the information
that I have, but I know that you have better information and I will
honor your decision. Although the foregoing may make it seem
otherwise, I don't have a strong opinion about this or any real
claim to certainty. I know it's not an easy decision to make
and I am praying that God will guide your thoughts and your decision
in accordance with His will and purpose.
I never had to make the decision – Mom died in the night.
But I hope you will take caution from my tale.
